MBC‘s rising Okay-Drama, My Dearest, achieved a viewership peak of 12.2 % in its newest episode, a substantial soar from its preliminary 5.4 %. Nonetheless, this success is now being tainted by allegations of plagiarism.
Critics and followers have seen a plethora of resemblances between My Dearest and the long-lasting novel, Gone with the Wind by Margaret Mitchell. This novel — later tailored into an award-winning Hollywood movie — appears to be the inspiration for lots of the Korean sequence’ plots and character arcs.
The first narrative of My Dearest revolves round two lovers set towards the backdrop of the Qing invasion of Joseon. Author Hwang Jin Younger has admitted that the epic story of Scarlett O’Hara from Gone with the Wind was an inspiration. Nonetheless, viewers imagine the similarities stretch past mere inspiration.
Yoo Gil Chae’s character, the feminine protagonist, intently mirrors the traits and actions of Scarlett O’Hara.
Lee Jang Hyun, the male lead, can simply be seen as Korea’s model of Rhett Butler. Each male characters exhibit an preliminary resistance to warfare and show a skeptical outlook on marriage, but succumb to the attract of their main girls.
Different characters from My Dearest additionally appear to echo these in Mitchell’s novel. The virtuous Nam Yeon Joon parallels Ashley Wilkes, whereas Kyung Eun Ae and Melanie Hamilton each painting the identical essence of knowledge and kindness. This record of comparable characters doesn’t cease right here, with even secondary characters reflecting a mirroring character or storyline in response to viewers.
Key plot factors in My Dearest even have uncanny resemblances to these in Gone with the Wind. Each tales present protagonists confessing their emotions, solely to be rejected and inadvertently witnessed by one other. The portrayal of warfare, its influence on people, and particular occasions throughout wartime appear to bear outstanding resemblance in each narratives.
One other noteworthy parallel is the transformation of the feminine protagonists. In each tales, they evolve from being self-centered to showcasing independence and resilience in occasions of adversity.
Regardless of these simple similarities, a authorized battle on copyright grounds appears unlikely. Copyright legal guidelines in Korea defend works for 70 years after the unique copyright holder’s demise. Since Gone with the Wind was printed in 1936 and Mitchell died in 1949, the copyright for the novel has lapsed.
The controversy is now centered on the ethics of such shut mirroring. Whereas some argue that the drama is merely a Korean adaptation of the traditional novel, others imagine crediting the inspiration doesn’t absolve it of plagiarism claims.
As anticipation builds for the subsequent episodes of My Dearest, it stays to be seen whether or not the drama will diverge from its Hollywood counterpart or proceed on this controversial trajectory.
Share This Submit